Can Domestic Violence Charges Be Dropped in Arizona?

Guidance for Tempe Residents Facing DV Allegations

Domestic violence (DV) allegations are among the most common charges filed in Arizona courts—and the consequences can be life-altering. Many clients ask: “If the alleged victim no longer wants to press charges, will the case go away?” Unfortunately, the answer is usually no. Once police make an arrest, the case belongs to the prosecutor, not the victim. Only the prosecutor (or the court) can dismiss the charges.

Victim Non-Cooperation & Prosecutorial Discretion

• No automatic dismissal. A victim’s request to “drop charges” does not compel the State to do so.
• Evidentiary hurdles. If the victim refuses to testify, the prosecutor must decide whether enough independent evidence exists—police body-cam, 911 audio, photographs, medical records, admissions, or eyewitnesses.
• Subpoenas & impeachment. Some county attorneys will subpoena reluctant victims. If a victim testifies inconsistently with earlier statements, prosecutors may impeach them with prior police reports or recordings.

Protective Orders vs. Criminal Charges

Orders of Protection (Civil)

Unlike criminal DV charges, an Order of Protection is a civil matter. The protected party may return to court and ask the judge to quash or modify the order. However, if a separate criminal case imposes no-contact conditions, those restrictions remain until the criminal judge changes them.

Release Conditions After Arrest

When domestic violence charges are filed, release conditions often prohibit contact with the alleged victim and may bar you from your own residence. Violating these terms—even if the victim initiates contact—can lead to re-arrest and additional charges. Always consult counsel before communicating with anyone protected by court order.

Strategies for Reducing or Dismissing DV Charges

An experienced defense attorney can:

• Analyze weaknesses in the State’s evidence (lack of independent proof, inconsistencies).
• Identify constitutional or procedural violations (unlawful arrest, Miranda issues).
• Work with the alleged victim’s wishes when appropriate and ethically permissible.
• Negotiate alternatives—diversion, counseling, or reduced, non-DV charges.

Facing a Domestic Violence Allegation in Tempe?

Ted Law offers decades of combined experience defending clients against domestic violence accusations throughout the East Valley. We understand the sensitive dynamics of DV cases—and how to protect your rights while seeking the best outcome.

Call (602) 453-3100 or contact us online for a free confidential consultation. We can meet by phone, video, or at our Tempe office.

 

 

For Residents Facing Criminal Allegations in Tempe

Domestic violence is a common charge in Arizona courts, and it often comes with confusion about what actually constitutes the offense. In many cases, accusations may be exaggerated or based on misunderstandings. Unfortunately, once the police are called, the state controls the case – regardless of whether the reporting individual rescinds their claim. If you or a loved one is dealing with a domestic violence charge, it’s crucial to understand Arizona’s legal framework and your defense options. Below is an overview of how domestic violence is defined and prosecuted in the state.

Understanding Arizona’s Domestic Violence Laws

What Counts as Domestic Violence?

Rather than defining a specific crime called “domestic violence,” Arizona law (A.R.S. § 13-3601) designates certain offenses as “domestic violence” if they involve a specific relationship between the accused and the alleged victim. Potentially related offenses include:

• Aggravated assault
• Animal cruelty
• Criminal damage
• Criminal trespassing
• Disorderly conduct
• Endangerment
• Harassment
• Kidnapping
• Manslaughter
• Murder
• Negligent homicide
• Physical assault
• Rape
• Sexual assault (including assault of a minor)
• Stalking
• Threatening or intimidating
• Unlawful imprisonment

Any of these crimes may be labeled “domestic violence” if the accused and the alleged victim have (or previously had) a romantic relationship, share a child, are blood relatives, are related by marriage, or reside/resided under the same roof. This broad definition means many disputes, even those that don’t involve physical harm, can lead to domestic violence charges if they fit the relationship criteria.

Penalties for Domestic Violence

Since “domestic violence” is a label rather than a standalone charge, penalties depend on the underlying offense. However, attaching domestic violence to a crime can increase sentencing severity, leading to:

• Longer jail or prison terms
• Limitations on probation or parole eligibility
• Mandatory counseling or classes
• Additional fines

Most domestic violence offenses are charged as misdemeanors in Arizona. The class of misdemeanor (Class 1, 2, or 3) dictates the maximum jail time and fines. For instance:

• Class 3 misdemeanor: Up to 30 days in jail, $500 in fines
• Class 2 misdemeanor: Up to 120 days in jail, $750 in fines
• Class 1 misdemeanor: Up to 180 days in jail, $2,500 in fines

Repeat offenders may face more significant consequences. If you’re convicted of domestic violence three times within an 84-month period, you could face Class 5 felony charges—bringing up to 2.5 years in prison. If the incident involves serious bodily injury, charges might increase to a Class 3 felony, carrying potential sentences of 5 to 15 years.

The Domestic Violence Court Process

The statute of limitations for a misdemeanor domestic violence charge in Arizona is generally one year. For felonies, the timeframe extends to seven years. Once a charge is filed, you will make an initial plea. Because domestic violence accusations often involve complex interpersonal dynamics, it’s wise to seek help from an experienced Tempe domestic violence defense attorney.

Your lawyer can assist in critical steps such as:

• Advising you on interactions with law enforcement
• Investigating the facts behind the alleged offense
• Negotiating with prosecutors for reduced or dismissed charges
• Representing you at trial if necessary

Possible Defenses

Some defenses against domestic violence charges include:

• Mistaken Identity (wrong person accused)
• Self-Defense or Defense of Others
• False Accusation or Exaggerated Claims
• Insufficient Evidence to prove the offense
• Police Misconduct (e.g., violating your rights)

A strong defense strategy could lead to the charges being dropped or reduced. It’s crucial to work with an attorney who understands both the legal and emotional complexities of domestic violence cases.

Contact Ted Law in Tempe for Domestic Violence Defense

If you’re facing domestic violence charges, don’t navigate Arizona’s criminal justice system alone. Ted Law offers robust legal representation tailored to your circumstances. Our team will examine the details of your case, identify the best defense strategies, and fight to protect your rights and future.

Call (602) 453-3100 or contact us online for a free consultation. We serve clients in Tempe and surrounding areas, providing the strong advocacy you deserve when facing serious allegations of domestic violence.

 

Roommate Disputes and Domestic Violence Charges in Tempe
Call (602) 453-3100 for a Free Consultation

When most people think of domestic violence, they picture spouses or romantic partners. However, in Arizona, domestic violence charges can arise in any situation where two or more people cohabit, including roommate relationships. If you’re a college student in Tempe, you should know how these charges can affect your education, housing, and future. Below is an overview of why domestic violence charges can occur between roommates and what you can do if you’ve been accused.

---

1. Roommates Can Be Considered “Cohabitants” Under Arizona Law

Under Arizona Revised Statutes, domestic violence charges are not limited to spouses or family members. Roommates—including those living in dorms or shared apartments—are considered cohabitants. If one roommate accuses another of a violent act or threat, the domestic violence label can apply, even if there is no romantic or familial relationship.

Key Point

Any form of violence or threat between cohabitants—friends, roommates, etc.—may be grounds for domestic violence charges.

---

2. Location of the Incident Doesn’t Matter

You might assume that a domestic violence charge must involve a dispute at home. However, fights can occur anywhere—on campus, at a party, or at a local bar—and still be classified as domestic violence if they involve cohabitants.

Examples

• Off-campus altercation: If you have a fight with your roommate on a night out, you could face domestic violence charges, in addition to other offenses like disorderly conduct or assault.
• Campus arguments: Even an on-campus disagreement that escalates physically can be viewed through the lens of domestic violence if you share living quarters.

---

3. The Seriousness of Domestic Violence Charges

Domestic violence can range from a misdemeanor to a felony in Arizona, depending on factors like:

• Severity of the injury
• Use of a weapon
• Any prior offenses

Aside from jail time or heavy fines, domestic violence convictions often result in additional consequences, such as:

• Restrictions on firearm ownership
• Protective orders that limit your freedom of movement
• Criminal record that can affect housing, job, and educational opportunities

Why You Should Seek Legal Help Immediately

Because a conviction could impact your future—including your standing at Arizona State University (ASU)—it’s crucial to consult with a Tempe domestic violence attorney right away.

---

4. What to Do If You’ve Been Accused

Facing a domestic violence accusation from a roommate or cohabitant can be overwhelming. Here’s how to protect your rights:

1. Remain Calm
   • Avoid further confrontation that could worsen the situation or lead to additional charges.
2. Contact an Attorney Promptly
   • Call (602) 453-3100 to speak with Ted Law, who has experience handling domestic violence cases in Tempe. Early legal intervention is vital to build a strong defense.
3. Gather Evidence
   • Write down details of the incident, collect any text messages or social media communications, and identify witnesses who can support your account.
4. Comply with All Court Orders
   • If a protective order or restraining order is issued, follow it strictly to avoid additional penalties.

---

5. How We Can Help

Attorney Theodore Agnick at Ted Law has extensive experience defending Tempe residents and ASU students against domestic violence allegations. We offer:

• Case Assessment: We’ll review your situation, clarify the charges, and explore any defenses or mitigating factors.
• Legal Guidance: Our team understands the complexities of Arizona’s domestic violence statutes and knows how to navigate Tempe’s legal system.
• Aggressive Defense: We strive to have charges reduced or dismissed, safeguarding your record and future opportunities.

---

Don’t Let a Domestic Violence Accusation Derail Your Future

Whether you’re living in a dorm, sharing an off-campus apartment, or simply cohabiting with friends, a single accusation of domestic violence can seriously affect your academic, professional, and personal life. If you find yourself in this stressful situation, act now to protect your rights and freedom.

Call (602) 453-3100 or reach out online for a free consultation. We’re here to discuss your options and develop a tailored legal strategy that aims to secure the best possible outcome for your case.

---

Disclaimer: This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For guidance on your specific case, please consult an attorney.